La Pecora Slice Shop Brings New York-Style Pizza Slices to Larchmere
Liam Cutwater · October 13, 2026
La Pecora Slice Shop lands on Larchmere with thin, crispy New York-inspired slices—walk-in, grab a bite, and taste Juan Vergara's spin.
If Larchmere felt a little less cheesy after Barroco Grill’s swan song, don’t worry—pizza salvation is here. The new La Pecora Slice Shop lands this month, slinging thin, crisp, New York-style slices right where the last Barroco sizzled out, courtesy of Cleveland’s own Vergara family.
A New Chapter for an Iconic Cleveland Family
Juan and Carlos Vergara made waves with Barroco Grill across Lakewood and beyond, but their latest act is all about pizza. La Pecora Slice Shop shares a wall—and a last name—with its fancier sibling, La Pecora Pizza Bar, but trades candlelight for counter service and a walk-in, no-reservation vibe. This spot is made for casual lunches, impromptu dinners, and those times you just need a perfect slice right now.
- Walk-in only, no reservations needed
- Family-friendly, 65-seat dining room
- Lunch and dinner, every day
What’s on the Menu? Crispy Slices & Easy Choices
If you’re picturing old-school, floppy New York pizza, think again—this Cleveland version stands up tall. The 18-inch pies are naturally leavened with a sourdough starter, giving every bite a tangy, artisan chew. Get your fix by the slice or the whole pie.
- Sourdough-based, thin & crispy pizza (not Neapolitan!)
- Sold by the slice or whole pie
- Simple selection of salads & pastas
- Menu designed to be quick, classic, and approachable
Why Larchmere Matters to the Vergaras
This is no cookie-cutter pizza joint. "This is a Larchmere creation that is unique to the neighborhood," says Juan Vergara. It’s about homegrown Cleveland style—bringing people together, with pizza as the glue. After shuttering all Barroco Grills, the Vergaras are betting it all on their east side block.
Expect a dash of culinary independence. Juan built a dough process that fuses New York tradition and Fermentation 101, instead of following the crowd. The result? Pizza that feels familiar but is totally its own thing.
Inside the Slice Shop: Laid-Back Cleveland Cool
The original La Pecora was built for intimate evenings, while the Slice Shop is all about letting your hair down with a dripping-hot slice. Open seating means you can roll in with friends, or fly solo—no stress. The counter-service layout keeps things quick; order up, grab a seat, and settle in while your pie’s crafted from scratch.
Can’t-Miss Highlights
- Open kitchen: Watch your pizza come to life
- Community vibe: Mix of locals, families, and pizza pilgrims
- Fast service but no rush—hang out as long as you want
Looking Ahead: The Next Pizza Chapter
Don’t expect the slice love to stop at Larchmere. With the Slice Shop revving up, the Vergaras are already plotting a pizza joint in Lakewood at their former Barroco space. Stay tuned—looks like Cleveland’s pizza game is just getting started.
Craving a perfect slice? Pop over to Larchmere and see (and taste) what all the buzz is about. Pizza in this town might never be the same.