First Look: Eugene Tavern Raises the Burger Bar in Chagrin Falls

Chagrin Falls scores a major burger upgrade as the Schoen Brothers unveil Eugene Tavern, serving smash burgers and clever tavern fare in a laid-back space.

Chagrin Falls just got an upgrade in the burger department, and it’s all thanks to the Schoen brothers. Eugene Tavern opened its doors this week, promising classic tavern vibes, craveable burgers, and enough local love to fill the old Flip Side-shaped hole in your heart.

The Vibe: Familiar Yet Fresh

Step through the doors at 44 N. Main St. and you’ll notice the three-month overhaul was worth it. Eugene Tavern feels both relaxed and genuinely new—think 65 seats, lots of welcoming wood, and a 12-seat bar perfect for chilling solo or corralling a date. Whether you’re grabbing a full dinner or just sliding up for a burger and a pint, this spot strikes the sweet spot between special-occasion and everyday hangout.

Menu Highlights: Smash Hits and More

Of course, the star of the show is the burger—and these aren’t just any burgers. Chef Michael Schoen brings back his hailed Tinman smash burger (from those legendary Ohio City Galley days), available as:

Single Tinman Smash Burger
Double Tinman Smash Burger
Half-pound Steak Burger (for big appetites)

But burgers are just the beginning. Some menu must-tries include:

Soft Pretzel with Jarlsberg Cheese Spread
Shrimp Toast
Buttermilk Fried Chicken Tenders with Hot Honey Drizzle
Three-step Tavern Fries (with herbs, parmesan, and malt vinegar aioli)

More Than Just Meat: Creative Plates for All

Craving more than beef? Eugene rounds things out with:

Steak Frites (grilled bavette)
Fish & Chips (Icelandic cod)
Grilled Ohio Pork Chop (with peach & sarsaparilla BBQ)
Grilled Cabbage Steak (topped with green goddess dressing)

And if you’re seeking sandwich action beyond the basic:

Fried Hot Chicken Sandwich
Beet & Pistachio Burger (vegetarian delight)
Griddled PB&J (pistachio butter, fig & cherry jam, Manchego cheese—trust us, it works)

When and How to Visit

Eugene Tavern is starting out with dinner service and weekend lunches, with weekday lunch rumored to join the schedule soon. Pro tip: Get there early—Chagrin Falls loves a new hangout spot, and this one already buzzes.

Why Eugene Matters: Filling a Local Need

After Flip Side closed, Chagrin was left burgerless. The Schoen brothers noticed—and delivered. Michael’s burger cred runs deep, and their new spot aims to keep things casual and approachable without skimping on flavor or hospitality. It’s destined to be that rare place: special enough for date night, easygoing enough for a weeknight burger and beer.

Coming Soon: The Schoen Empire Expands

Here’s a local scoop—Barbecue Gene, the brothers’ next venture, will bring smoked meats, rotisserie birds, and all the proper sides to North Collinwood in the coming years. For now, though, you’ll want to hit Chagrin for your burger fix.

Ready to burger up? Chagrin’s waiting—and Eugene Tavern delivers the goods.