Benny Lorenzo’s Brings Giant Slices to Ohio City
Liam Cutwater · September 8, 2026
Benny Lorenzo’s, famous for mammoth 28-inch pizza, is spicing up Ohio City’s food scene. Here’s what to expect when it lands on West 25th.
In a move sure to ignite cheesy debates and late-night cravings, Benny Lorenzo’s—Cleveland’s first outpost of the cult-favorite Benny’s Pizza chain—will soon serve up 28-inch pies in the heart of Ohio City. With its Virginia roots and reputation for larger-than-life slices, this opening is set to put West 25th Street on the map for big pizza energy.
What to Expect from Benny Lorenzo’s
If you think you know pizza, think again. Benny Lorenzo’s isn’t your average New York-style joint. The main event: a behemoth 28-inch pie that’s basically a table-sized flex. Their menu will feature:
- 28-inch NY-style pizzas (yes, that’s bigger than your tire)
- Giant, foldable slices perfect for street strolls
- A simple menu with classic toppings: cheese, pepperoni, sausage, and a rotating specialty
Each Benny’s location keeps it streamlined, so expect quality and speed over a million combos.
Where to Find It
This newcomer is claiming a piece of the former Family Dollar space on bustling West 25th Street. Nestled right in the thick of Ohio City’s food-and-bar paradise, Benny Lorenzo’s will be neighbors with:
- West Side Market
- A fleet of independent bars and eateries
- The city’s best people-watching patio spots
Translation: easy to grab a slice before, after, or during your night out.
Why Ohio City? And Why Now?
Ohio City has built its rep on unique, independent food spots. But lately, the block is sharing space with bigger brands like Chipotle and now Benny Lorenzo’s. Some locals might raise eyebrows, but let’s be real—if you bring a 28-inch pizza to a party, you’re welcome.
The crowds on West 25th aren’t the only thing that keeps growing. This latest opening reflects a trend of out-of-town chains choosing Cleveland’s food-forward neighborhoods for expansion.
What Makes Benny’s Different
Unlike most pizza chains, every Benny’s goes by a unique name (the others: Benny DiCarta’s, Benny Mazzetto’s, etc.). Cleveland gets Benny Lorenzo’s, a nod that feels just mysterious enough to become an insider rally cry.
Things they don’t mess with:
- Over-stuffed menus
- Trend-chasing gimmicks
- Pretending their slices won’t require both hands
When You Can Try It
There’s no confirmed opening date yet, but the arrival is imminent. Keep your eyes peeled as construction wraps in the coming weeks.
Hours and more specifics are under wraps, but you can bet Benny’s signature style will draw lines the minute those doors open.
The Bottom Line
Whether you’re a pizza purist or just hungry for a new spot to carb-load, Benny Lorenzo’s brings that go-big-or-go-home attitude Clevelanders secretly love. Watch this space—Ohio City’s about to experience its biggest slice yet.