Agave & Rye Shutters Eton Chagrin Blvd. in Woodmere—What It Means for East Side Taco Lovers
Liam Cutwater · September 21, 2026
Agave & Rye closed its Eton Chagrin location in Woodmere, leaving east siders searching for a new go-to for gourmet tacos and creative cocktails.
Blink and you might've missed it: Agave & Rye closed its doors at Eton Chagrin Blvd. in Woodmere, leaving many east side taco enthusiasts in mourning. The bold gourmet taco spot made waves when it arrived in the east suburbs, but just two and a half years later, it's already part of Cleveland dining lore.
The Story Behind the Shutdown
Opening in the former Paladar space, Agave & Rye was the second Cleveland-area outpost for the Kentucky-based mini-chain. Despite a quirky menu and ambitious cocktails, the Woodmere spot is now history. No official reason has been given for the closure, but it appears only the Eton location is affected—downtown fans, you’re safe (for now).
A Short But Spicy Run at Eton
When Agave & Rye opened, it promised over-the-top tacos, bold murals, and a margarita list as long as a CVS receipt. Geauga and east Cuyahoga County folks rejoiced at not having to schlep downtown for unique takes like:
- Mac & Cheese Taco
- Korean BBQ Taco
- Loaded "Epic" burritos
- Chloe-approved frozen margs & tequila flights Months later? The Woodmere outpost never quite found its audience, even with its Instagram-bait interiors and whiskey-soaked brunches.
What This Means for Woodmere’s Food Scene
Eton Chagrin Blvd. has always been a revolving door for buzzworthy restaurants. Agave & Rye's exit follows Paladar's, and others before that. For diners, it’s one less option for creative tacos and fun cocktails east of Cedar Road.
But Woodmere’s reputation as a dining playground for east siders is safe. Neighbors like:
- Blu, the Restaurant (seafood)
- Pacific East (sushi)
- Mabel’s BBQ spin-off still draw crowds, and another concept will likely snap up the spot. (Maybe bring back a classic diner? We can hope!)
Where to Get Your Agave & Rye Fix Now
Craving those anything-goes tacos? You’re not left totally high and dry. The dazzling Agave & Rye in the Warehouse District (1352 W. 6th St.) is still open and slinging:
- Epic taco creations
- Wild whiskey pairings
- Their signature “epic” ambiance So if you’re willing to venture west, your craving can still be satisfied.
What’s Next for the Eton Space?
No official word yet on what will fill the Agave & Rye space. Given Eton Chagrin’s high profile, you can bet a new comer will land sooner than later. The only guarantee? Cleveland suburbanites will continue their endless debate about who does tacos best—and you better believe we’ll be there to cover it.
Looking for your next taco adventure? Keep it locked to TasteCLE for the latest on openings, closings, and where’s actually worth your time around Cleveland.